In Addition to the rooms we have reserved especially for our wedding guests (listed below), a complete list of hotels in the area can be found here.


On the Island :

Accommodations are VERY, VERY difficult to find on Shelter Island so book early. We are holding the following rooms until May 1st.

Olde Country Inn
Contact Franz or Jeanne at 631-749-1633
Room Rates: $155.00 - $275.00

Must be booked for three nights. 13 Rooms.

The inn dates back to the 1880's when its hotel guests were picked up at the ferries by horse and buggy. Its turn-of-the-century charm is still maintained by the family, and their guests are offered that same old fashioned friendly hospitality. In the early nineties they renovated and updated the entire inn. The beautiful front porch welcomes you to sit awhile and "watch the world go by." The pavilion in the back garden adds a romantic touch to the warm weather dining. Delicious breakfasts and unforgettable dinners are served here.

Sunset Beach
Room Rates: Over $300.00
2 Rooms

Sunset Beach is the hottest spot on Shelter Island . The restaurant is quite good and the beach bar has become a Mecca for Hamptonites and high profile types as an after-hours must-be-seen spot. The hotel is set back away from the action a bit and each room has been renovated and has a terrace overlooking the beach.


In Nearby Greenport:

Harbor Front Inn
Contact 631-477-8661
Room Rates: $259 - $399 (for Jr. Suites)
10 Rooms

Across the Ferry in the cute little fishing village of Greenport , this hotel has 30 rooms which have been reserved. Some of the more expensive rooms have water views, offering views of Shelter Island . The ferry ride is only 7 minutes long and it is a very short walk to the church from the ferry. Private Pool.


Other Hotels That We Have NOT Reserved

We have not checked these hotels personally but they all look cute in photographs…

The Candlelite Inn
Contact 631-749-0676

House on Chase Creek
Contact 631-749-4379